FAQ - Tune Dem

What is the Tune Dem™?

The Linn philosophy is very simple – if it sounds better, it is better. The Tune Dem™ is how we recommend that our products are demonstrated.

When carrying out an A-B demonstration, it is sometimes possible to be confused by extraneous factors such as loudness and tone. The Tune Dem™ is a way to compare the two products and decide on how easy it is to follow the tune and appreciate the musical piece as a whole on each one – this allows you to hear quite clearly which product sounds better. The method involves silent repetition of the sound from the loudspeakers, silently singing along simultaneously with the sound from the speaker. The easier this is to do, the more accurate the system performance.

The Tune

Our favourite method of evaluating the musical performance, and thus the performance of the hi-fi, is simply listening to the tune.

Many people immediately dismiss this as being the obviously too simplistic to provide meaningful results. But, in actual practice, this is an all-encompassing technique that more clearly brings out the differences in hi-fi systems than any other method of evaluation that we have ever used.

The music on a record consists of a signal that, at any instant, can be described with tow parameters, frequency and amplitude (or pitch and loudness, of you prefer).

Any type of distortion, whether or not we can measure it or understand it, will change frequency, amplitude or both. That is, by definition, what distortion does. And it rarely does this in a linear manner. That is, some frequencies or amplitudes are changed more than others are.

These changes in frequency and amplitude will change the pitch relations in the music and thus alter the tune. For example – since the perceived pitch of a note consists of the sum of its fundamental plus its harmonics, a distortion that adds extra harmonics will shift the pitch of that note up slightly. Likewise, a distortion that results in the rolling-off of higher frequencies (thus reducing the amplitude of some harmonics) can lower the perceived pitch.

Our musical scale is composed of a series of fixed steps. These steps are predictable. Our brain has an uncanny ability to follow those steps and to determine when errors have been made. It is much like climbing a set of stairs. As long as all the steps are the same you can comfortably walk up the steps, come down the steps, run up, run down, take two steps at a time, even do it in the dark. However, change the size of just one step and you are likely to fall on your face.

Following the tune is much the same. If you try to follow along with the tune you will find that, on a good hi-fi system, the tune will seem to make more sense. The steps will be more regular. The notes that one instrument is playing will have some relationship to the notes that another instrument produces. You will even frequently know what note is coming next.

In the end, the better the system the less damage it does to the pitch relationships and the easier it is to follow the tune. And, since any type of distortion, regardless of its source, must alter the tune, this method is a comprehensive test of a hi-fi system’s musical performance.

Tune-Dem method

The approach we suggest when doing an A/B comparison is to listen to component A, then listen to B. If one sounds better, buy it. If they both sound the same, buy the least expensive one. Anything else is folly. We have always said, “If it sounds better, then it is better.”

You will find it easier to compare components in an A/B situation if you play only a brief passage (as little as ten seconds and certainly no more than thirty seconds) on one component. Repeat this brief passage a few times on the first product then switch to the second component and play the same passage.

By keeping the passages short, you will the “tune” fresh in your mind and will be better able to judge the relative difficulties following the tune on each component.

If you should have any problems in detecting differences in the ease with which you can follow the tune when doing comparisons, don’t panic. Just sit back, relax and try again. A few simple questions can help follow the Tune:

• Can you hear all the musicians playing all of the instruments all of the time?

• Can you always follow the tune played by every instrument?

• How easy is it to sing-along/follow with the melody?

The remarkable thing is that once you do hear the difference you will find that it is much more apparent than you originally thought. And the more you listen the easier this method will become. With a little practice, you will find that you have a listening test that is consistent, repeatable, and best of all, a very reliable indicator of the performance of any hi-fi component.

A simple way to find how Tuneful a hifi is: Play a full track and follow the Tune/melody. Mute the speakers for a short time (e.g. 5-10 seconds), half way through the track and continue the tune in your head. When you unmute the speakers, are you in time with the playback tune. This will find how easy the hifi system allows you to follow the Tune.

Note:
Avoid the use of comparators or switching boxes. The extra connectors will degrade the signal of both components under test, frequently bringing the level of performance down to that of the switch box, making any meaningful evaluation impossible.

For similar reasons we strongly suggest that all component evaluations be done in a demonstration room that contains only one set of loudspeakers. Additional speakers even though not being used will vibrate in sympathy with the original sound source. This added noise does make it more difficult to evaluate components. Not only does it make it harder to judge the tune, it tends to favour a component that is more aggressive sounding and unfairly penalises a good component by masking some of the low-level detailed information that only the best components are capable of reproducing.